Review by Eddie AI

Time-stamped feedback on your video frm your team & AI. Free

Productivity

Artificial Intelligence

Video

Visit WebsiteSee on Product HuntTwitter ⧉Instagram ⧉

I've been waiting for an AI editor that integrates with my existing workflow. One feature I'd love to see is more control over the auto-generated rough cuts, maybe some sliders for adjusting pace and tone. That would make Eddie a game-changer for my team.

Feedback loops are such an underrated part of the video workflow — most tools focus entirely on creation and leave review as an afterthought (usually a messy Slack thread). Is the AI feedback purely technical (exposure, cuts, pacing) or does it try to assess narrative/messaging too? Curious where you've drawn that line.

A great product and great fit for video editing in this AI era. looking forward to try and congrats on the launch!

The no-login, share-with-unlimited-people flow is great for speed, but it also means anyone holding the link can view and comment on your unreleased cut. For agency work on embargoed client content, is there a way to expire or revoke a review link once that round of feedback is collected, or does it stay live indefinitely once it's shared? Feels like the kind of thing that's fine right up until a client's unreleased ad ends up forwarded into the wrong group chat.

@fahad good to know, I'll give it a real try this week on an actual project instead of just poking at the demo. does the "sharper over time" part mean it's learning from my specific comment history, or is it more of a general model upgrade that happens for everyone at once?

@amdfad Upvoted this today. Free-tier products need the first email to convert fast before people forget why they signed up, curious how that's handled.

The no-login, time-stamped feedback that becomes a to-do list is exactly the friction I hit sharing cuts with non-editors - they leave vague "the middle drags" notes with no timecode. Day-one question: does a reviewer just open a rendered preview link, or do they need anything installed? And when a note turns into a to-do, does it carry the exact timecode back into Premiere or Resolve so I jump straight to that frame, or is it a separate checklist I have to line up against the timeline myself?

Congrats on the launch! The extension integrations are what stand out here: meeting editors where they already work rather than asking them to leave their timeline is the right call, and native R3D and BRAW ingestion is a detail that will matter a lot to the people who need it.

Curious how Eddie handles pacing decisions, specifically when there's no script to anchor against. For something like a run-and-gun interview where the story only becomes clear in the edit, how does it decide what to cut versus what to keep?

Any plans for batch/API access? If this could fit into our remote video editor pipeline, that would be epic

the "ask Eddie to review your edit before a human sees it" part is the feature I'd actually use daily. so much of editing feedback is just catching your own pacing/continuity mistakes before someone else has to point them out, and doing that at 2am before a client call is a real problem worth solving. does the AI review get sharper over time based on what your team actually flags as important vs what it flags, or is it the same generic pass every time regardless of who's on the review?

Robbie, anyone who has traded muddled notes back and forth on a cut will feel the relief here. Getting feedback to land exactly where it belongs takes so much friction out of the whole thing. Really tidy.

Hey PH fam 👋

Super excited to bring Eddie Review to the global tech and startup community today.

I hunted Eddie AI’s first version back in October 2024 when they reimagined editing with AI. Today they're going after the part of video production nobody builds for: the feedback loop.

Here's the thing about video work. The cut is never done when the editor says it's done. It's done when the team, the client, and the stakeholders say it's done. That review round-trip is where timelines quietly die. Version 7 in the group chat. Notes like "fix the middle part." A link that expires before the client opens it.

Eddie Review compresses that whole loop into minutes:

→ Share a cut and collect frame-accurate comments, no login or re-upload needed
→ Ask Eddie AI to review your edit before a human ever sees it (this part genuinely surprised me)
→ Every note becomes a to-do list you can actually work through

The AI review is the piece I'd watch closely. It's like having a second pair of editor eyes on your cut at 2am before the client call at 9. You catch the pacing issue yourself instead of hearing about it in the meeting.

And it's free. Not free trial. Just free.

Built by @amdfad @shamirallibhai and the Eddie team, who've been quietly building the full stack of agentic video tools for pros. They're all here today.

One thing that would make Eddie even more useful for me is multi-language transcript support for interview cuts. Half my interviews are in Spanish and a few in Portuguese, and right now the auto-detect struggles with mixed-language dialogue. Adding a clean way to switch transcription language mid-project (or auto-detect per speaker) would save a ton of cleanup time before the rough cut lands in Premiere.

honestly the multi cam podcast support sounds great but it would be really useful to have some kind of auto transcription search so i can jump to specific moments in long interviews without scrubbing through the whole timeline

The multicam sync is already a lifesaver for my podcast edits, so thanks for that. One thing that would make a real difference for me is a quick way to flag and pull only the best hook moments from long interview files, basically a highlight reel generator I can drop straight into a timeline.

Timestamped feedback beats "make it pop" comments in a doc, no contest. I build approval flows for written content and the pattern matches: feedback anchored to the exact spot kills half the revision cycles. Does Eddie's AI feedback ever disagree with the human reviewers, and who wins?

honestly this looks super useful for cutting down interview footage way faster. one thing that would help a lot is being able to save your own custom prompt templates for different types of edits, like a specific style for youtube shorts vs a documentary feel, so you dont have to re explain the tone every single time

How does Eddie AI decide which feedback is actually useful versus just subjective opinions?

Honestly, this was such a joy to work on!!! We were initially using this internally. We loved iterating on it, making it better, and ultimately sharing it w our video friends -- and we've heard such great things and have seen so many people take advantage of this free review tool that we are now opening it up to the wider community.

I am so, so excited to see how you use it and hear your feedback about how we can make it better! Like Shamir said, feedback is a gift, and making timestamped video comments expensive is a tax on video storytelling, which we definitely want to lift 💪