This product was not featured by Product Hunt yet. It will not be visible on their landing page and won't be ranked (cannot win product of the day regardless of upvotes).
Product upvotes vs the next 3
Waiting for data. Loading
Product comments vs the next 3
Waiting for data. Loading
Product upvote speed vs the next 3
Waiting for data. Loading
Product upvotes and comments
Waiting for data. Loading
Product vs the next 3
Loading
Should I Really?
Crowd Advice for Real Decisions
Ever stuck on a decision? Should I? is where you crowdsource life's tough calls. Post your dilemma—quit your job, confront your roommate, buy that car—and get instant votes + real advice from people who've been there. Vote Yes/No in seconds, dive deep in comments, or just lurk on juicy decisions. Community-powered wisdom meets Reddit-style engagement. Earn Rep for helpful advice, follow outcomes to see what people actually did. From career moves to relationship drama, we've got your back. 🤔➡️✅
Hey Product Hunt! 👋 I'm excited to launch Should I Really?
The problem: We've all been there - stuck between two choices, asking friends who tell you what they think you want to hear, or posting on Reddit and getting buried.
The solution: A dedicated space where: You post your dilemma in 30 seconds Community votes Yes/No + explains why You see diverse perspectives instantly You come back and share what you actually did
Why it works: Quick votes (2 sec) get you instant pulse checks Deep comments give you the "why" behind the votes Rep system rewards genuinely helpful people Outcome tracking closes the loop (most advice platforms never tell you what happened!)
Anti-troll features baked in: AI content moderation + 3-strike system Pseudonymous but not anonymous (build reputation, stay private)
Fun stuff: Categories: Career, Relationships, Big Purchases, Living Situations, Time-Sensitive decisions Mark the comment that helped most (awards Rep) See what % voted Yes vs No
Current status: Just launched the Web Platform!
Mobile apps (iOS/Android) to follow
What I'd love feedback on:
What decisions would YOU post? Is 2 posts/day enough or too restrictive? What features am I missing?
Thanks for checking it out! Happy to answer any questions. And hey... should I really have launched on a Tuesday instead? 😄
About Should I Really? on Product Hunt
“Crowd Advice for Real Decisions”
Should I Really? was submitted on Product Hunt and earned 3 upvotes and 1 comments, placing #99 on the daily leaderboard. Ever stuck on a decision? Should I? is where you crowdsource life's tough calls. Post your dilemma—quit your job, confront your roommate, buy that car—and get instant votes + real advice from people who've been there. Vote Yes/No in seconds, dive deep in comments, or just lurk on juicy decisions. Community-powered wisdom meets Reddit-style engagement. Earn Rep for helpful advice, follow outcomes to see what people actually did. From career moves to relationship drama, we've got your back. 🤔➡️✅
On the analytics side, Should I Really? competes within Productivity, Social Media and Tech — topics that collectively have 1.4M followers on Product Hunt. The dashboard above tracks how Should I Really? performed against the three products that launched closest to it on the same day.
Who hunted Should I Really??
Should I Really? was hunted by Daniel Swanepoel. A “hunter” on Product Hunt is the community member who submits a product to the platform — uploading the images, the link, and tagging the makers behind it. Hunters typically write the first comment explaining why a product is worth attention, and their followers are notified the moment they post. Around 79% of featured launches on Product Hunt are self-hunted by their makers, but a well-known hunter still acts as a signal of quality to the rest of the community. See the full all-time top hunters leaderboard to discover who is shaping the Product Hunt ecosystem.
For a complete overview of Should I Really? including community comment highlights and product details, visit the product overview.
Daniel Swanepoel
Hey Product Hunt! 👋
I'm excited to launch Should I Really?
The problem:
We've all been there - stuck between two choices, asking friends who tell you what they think you want to hear, or posting on Reddit and getting buried.
The solution:
A dedicated space where:
You post your dilemma in 30 seconds
Community votes Yes/No + explains why
You see diverse perspectives instantly
You come back and share what you actually did
Why it works:
Quick votes (2 sec) get you instant pulse checks
Deep comments give you the "why" behind the votes
Rep system rewards genuinely helpful people
Outcome tracking closes the loop (most advice platforms never tell you what happened!)
Anti-troll features baked in:
AI content moderation + 3-strike system
Pseudonymous but not anonymous (build reputation, stay private)
Fun stuff:
Categories: Career, Relationships, Big Purchases, Living Situations, Time-Sensitive decisions
Mark the comment that helped most (awards Rep)
See what % voted Yes vs No
Current status: Just launched the Web Platform!
Mobile apps (iOS/Android) to follow
What I'd love feedback on:
What decisions would YOU post?
Is 2 posts/day enough or too restrictive?
What features am I missing?
Thanks for checking it out! Happy to answer any questions. And hey... should I really have launched on a Tuesday instead? 😄